Monday 9 April 2012

24.2 Master Planned Beach Resort Destination Checklist – Part 2 – Natural Environment

This subject check list covers the first of the 5 main subjects from the Master Check List - Components of the Ideal Master Planned Beach Resort Destination.  These subject check lists are by no means comprehensive, but more like a shopping list with brief explanations as reminders.  This check list series actually goes hand in hand with an earlier series I posted on Integrated Master Planning for Destination Development.   This check list would actually be similar to some of the outlines for the phase of Environmental / Site Analysis in the Integrated Master Planning methodology.    

Clear waters and white sandy beaches the basic ingredients.


Private coves with beaches ideal for boutique hotels.


Agricultural landscapes such as rice terraces can provide scenic views.

Mangoves serve environmental purposes and are good tour features.

Clear waters and abundant marine life makes snorkeling a must do activity.

The natural environment and its beauty is so important and is the most important asset to any Beach Resort Destination.  It is important that the natural resources are properly evaluated, documented, managed and put to highest and best use without over stressing the environment beyond its natural carrying capacity.  As we know with some infamous cases of beach resorts so polluted by sewage it no longer becomes a place where tourists are willing to swim and hence the end to the whole destination. 
Being dependent on nature, this subject check list of Natural Environment is probably the list that most needs to be inherent to a location and intact for the development of a Beach Resort Destination to be viable.  It is highly unlikely (although not completely impossible) that most of the features below can be manmade!

A.      NATURAL ENVIRONMENT
No.
Aspects
Features
Implications
1.
Climate
Tropical Temperature

Year round temperature should be warm enough to make beach activities attractive.  Temperature should be above 24 degrees Celsius.
Rainfall

Tropical rains can give a fresh cooling environment, but if seasonal rains are nonstop for days or weeks, could result in low season.
Wind

Cool breezes are welcomed, but excessive winds combined with tropical rains can limit the use of outdoor spaces even if covered.  Good for wind and kite surfing.
Extreme Conditions

Typhoons, monsoons, etc. if too frequent or too extreme could result in having certain times of year labeled no travel / no operations seasons.
2.
Coastal Environment
Sandy Beaches

A must!  Powder white sand considered the most attractive.  One long stretch at least 2km is ideal for a main public beach and town. 
Private Coves

Makes good locations for boutique hotels or other unique experiences.
Rocky Headlands

Adds variety to the shoreline.  Usually associated with the ends of private coves.
Tide Pools

Usually low tide conditions ideal for viewing small marine life.
Off Shore Islands

Provides picturesque vistas from the near shore developments.  Also can become a destination for tourists, usually associated with good coral reef snorkeling locations.
Mangrove Estuary

More diversity to the shoreline, the mangrove provides a breeding ground and nursery for young fish and prawns.  Also serves as filter for inland water runoff.
Coastal Forest

Important feature in maintaining shoreline stability and avoiding coastal erosion. 
3.
Marine Environment
Water Quality

Free of industrial and human waste pollutants.  Visibility enough to clearly view coral and marine life will make snorkeling and diving enjoyable.
Marine Life

Off shore or nearby coral reef and marine life is a major tourist attraction.  Destructive fishing practices such as dynamite is a real negative activity / impact.
Surf Conditions

Generally calm water is universally attractive.  Wave, wind and kite surfing in certain locations or time of year is an added feature.
4.
Inland Environment
Flat Lands

A good stretch located next to a long stretch of sandy beach is good location for a beach town and can become the heart of all activities.
Hilly Topography

Rolling hills behind the flat areas in front of the beach and some areas slopping down to the beach are ideal for accommodations to take advantage of views to the water.
Forest

Inland areas with unique flora and fauna are added attractions.  Waterfalls and rivers / streams provide tourism opportunities.
Agriculture Land

Certain agriculture lands could make picturesque landscape views to add to give variety to sea views, ie rice terraces.  In addition agriculture activities can be interesting tourist activities.
Copyright: Jiwa Studio Pte. Ltd. 2012


Link to other parts of the series:
Master Planned Beach Resort Destination Checklist

Part 1 – Overview
Part 2 – Natural Environment
Part 3 – Access / Proximity
Part 4 – Development Products
Part 5 – Supporting Infrastructure and Services
Part 6 – Destination Management

Jiwa Studio, Singapore
April 2012

11 comments:

  1. • Hi Bertram, I want to know more about Agricultural landscapes Such As rice terraces can Provide scenic views, it is possible that enivies more information?

    Edgar Benavides
    (from Linkedin Intl. Urban Planning and Regional Planning Group discussion)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Edgar

      Sea views are great, but ultimately they are all very similar if they only look at the horizon where sky meets sea. For me the more interesting is alway down the shore line or to off shore islands. And in some cases where there is foreground in the view to the sea which is unique. This could possibly be more of an agricultural landscape.

      Besides this island development usually have a lot of inland areas and sometime being on an island resort / beach resort doesn't mean being at the beach for 100% of the time. I guess one can argue that then the destination is not just a beach resort!

      I am not sure if that was your question?

      Delete
    2. Thanks, very interesting scenario you describe,

      Edgar Benavides
      (from Linkedin Intl. Urban Planning and Regional Planning Group discussion)

      Delete
  2. Bertram - A fine presentation and a generalized methodology with which I can find no fault. Should be valuable in initial work on any destination development project. It is, however, generalized, and in practice over many years I have been challenged to devise a unique detailed approach to just about every project I've encountered. This is not to find anything lacking in yours, only to emphasize that the professional needs to pay considerable attention to uniqueness of place (genius loci), local and state laws and regulations, special environmental sensitivities, how "destination" can be defined (particularly if/where the site lacks a single outstanding mind-blowing/profit-assuring characteristic), what can possibly be "invented" (based preferably on genuine local assets and heritage) to make up for the absence of a major magnet if none can be introduced, and ensuring that ALL stakeholders - and the public - are invited into the process. (But I'm sure you are on top of all this, which is presumably found elsewhere in your Integrated Master Planning publication). Good luck with it. *******

    In passing, I might mention several of our (The Rivers Studio's) projects, in which unique challenges were faced and in which a strong degree of inventiveness was required to make up for the absence of an inherent magnet: 1) The Erie Canal Heritage Waterfront Pan, for the Buffalo, NY, downtown riverfront - which is now nearing completion and which will effectively transform a desolate urban 40 acres into a regional tourism and dining.retail/entertainment magnet. The key: unearthing and restoring long-buried sections of the Erie Canal. 2) The Plan for a near-mile length of the Indiana Central Canal in Indianapolis - The key: to lower the canal 12 feet and create a San Antonio-styled "canalwalk". Completed in 1989, this project has brought in many millions in development and tax yield. 3) My concept and plan for the Bricktown Canal in Oklahoma City. No canal had existed here or anywhere within several hundred miles, but my vision was to create one to produce the magnet that was lacking here. Completed in 1997 at the cost of $37 million, the project has drawn more than $4 billion in development and tax yield. 4) Though much smaller scaled, the master plans and other consultations for beach and resort communities along the lower Texas Gulf coast are having positive effect and within the near future should be drawing many thousands of beach-goers, vacationers, ecotourists, and others. ***

    Best wishes.
    Roy B. Mann, ASLA
    (from Linkedin Urban Design Network discussion)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Roy thanks for your comments and introduction of your projects. Yes the methodology is generalized and you do need to tailor to specific projects. I always tell my colleagues this is just the frame work to use as a starting point to have some discipline and as a way to check along the way to make sure you maintain enough discipline.


      I like your point about what I would call having "no unique selling point",

      "....how "destination" can be defined (particularly if/where the site lacks a single outstanding mind-blowing/profit-assuring characteristic), what can possibly be "invented" (based preferably on genuine local assets and heritage) to make up for the absence of a major magnet...."

      This is always the most difficult question / problem. This is where true creativity and innovation comes in and a "new expression" or "redefining" of the local environment / culture can become the innovation. This is something that includes the environment, architecture, design, lanscape, branding, operations culture, etc. and carries out through out all the aspects of the destination.

      In some ways this is equally or even more exciting than responding to an existing strong physical / cultural context!

      Delete
  3. • Your blogs always have much value. Thanks

    John Davenport
    (from Linkedin Asian Resort Developer discussion)

    ReplyDelete
  4. • Thanks, Bertram. The integrated approach to master planning beach resort destinations is key to the success of the project.
    Our company has developed a very similar approach, which is specific to marina development. We have had our best experiences when we can insert our integrated marina development approach into this type of integrated resort destination planning.
    For the overall resort, our services include infrastructure engineering, environmental impact studies, coastal engineering, environmental design, etc. But for marinas, in addition to all the technical disciplines, we do our own marina market studies (in coordination with the overall resort market study), we activley participate in the marina siting and planning (side by side with the planners and architects), and we develop integrated marina feasibility studies and business plans for the marina as a business unit.

    Esteban Biondi
    (from Linkedin Asian Resort Developer discussion)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nice one! I'm really interested to know more about how we can practice ecotourism on beaches without harming the place.

    Duarte Dellarole
    (from Linkedin Ecotourism Network discussion)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Duarte

      I think it is more a question of determining the acceptable impact and managing such that impact is as minimal as possible. Then there has to be the evaluaton of the social benefits of the development to offset the acceptable impact. If we look for zero impact, then there is little chance for us to enjoy natural environments other than by photos!

      Delete
  6. I think there are issues related to tourist activity ocean that could support at the next meeting in Rio 20 this issue is relevant. The tourist may well receive guidance:

    - Sea and natural processes on the coast
    - Artisanal fishermen and their culture in the use of marine resources.
    - Promoting awareness of the situation of the oceans and the need to protect
    - Species and symbiosis in front of the resort or in the immediate ecosystem
    - Artistic manifestations arising from contact with the coast community

    Magnificent topic

    Antonio Rico
    (from Linkedin Ecotourism Network discussion)

    ReplyDelete
  7. In degraded habitats/ecosystems development provides resources for restoration, either through recreation & ecotourism (positive) or through mitigation for damages (negative).
    to blow my own horn: www.seascapecarib.com

    Andrew Ross
    (from Linkedin Ecotourism Network discussion)

    ReplyDelete

Please keep comments brief. Thanks for visiting our site. Jiwa Studio.